ARMYs Outraged Over Apparent Double-Standard During BTS’s “2022 GRAMMYs” Nomination Event Appearance
본문
Earlier today, the Recording Academy announced the nominees for the 2022 GRAMMYs Awards show (also known as the 64th GRAMMY Awards).
CEO Harvey Mason Jr. and Board of Trustees Chair Tammy Hurt revealed the nominees for the upcoming GRAMMYs with assistance from celebrities and artists. The music artists included K-Pop group BTS, musician Jon Batiste, four-time GRAMMY Award winner H.E.R., rock band Måneskin, singer-songwriter Carly Pearce, music artist Tayla Parx, singer-songwriter Billie Eilish, singer-songwriter FINNEAS, and more.
During the 2022 GRAMMYs Awards Show Nominations Livestream Event, CBS Mornings anchor Gayle King announced that BTS was nominated for “Best Pop Duo/Group Performance” for “Butter.” They are up against Coldplay‘s “Higher Power,” “Kiss Me More” by Doja Cat featuring SZA, “I Get a Kick Out of You” by Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga, and “Lonely” by Justin Bieber and Benny Blanco.
After BTS’s one GRAMMY nomination was revealed, BTS appeared to announce another category of nominations: “Best Alternative Music Album.” The group read the nominees which are as follows: “Shore” by Fleet Foxes, “If I Can’t Have Love, I Want Power” by Halsey, “Jubilee” by Japanese Breakfast, “Collapsed in Sunbeams” by Arlo Parks, and “Daddy’s Home” by St. Vincent.
While other artists were given multiple categories to announce the nominations, the seven BTS members had to take turns announcing the five nominees for this one category.
[VIDEO] @BTS_twt #BTSxGrammys
BTS announcing the "Best Alternative Music Album" category nnominees for The 64th GRAMMY's. pic.twitter.com/19wdT0c4sk
— Dalbit Bangtan⁷ (@dalbitbangtan) November 23, 2021
Still, that’s not what upset netizens the most regarding the Recording Academy’s treatment of BTS. Many noticed that while the other celebrity presenters were given descriptions under their name, BTS were not, despite being nominated for a GRAMMY the previous year.
그래도 오늘 발표 전까지 1 time nominee 했던 그룹인데 밑에 자막로도 안달아줬어, 다른분들은 전에 노미되었거나 수상했음 자막으로 붙던데..한번 했으면 안달아주는 건가? 원래 두번 이상 해야만 달아주는 거야? pic.twitter.com/6VYXZGdKvu
— 흑진주 (jinjoo) (@jjooSG93) November 23, 2021
this is still a group that’s been a 1 time nominee before today’s announcement. They didn’t even add that subtitle/caption for them. Other artists were given the caption if they were nominated or won the award…do they not give you a subtitle if you’ve only been nominated once? Do they usually only put the subtitle for you after you’ve been nominated more than once?
— @jjooSG93/Twitter
HOLD ON YOU GOTTA BE FUCKING KIDDING ME???????? pic.twitter.com/oeQr8WGVR8
— 제이
(@dionysusvrrs) November 23, 2021
Not only were GRAMMY winners credited but so were other artists who have been nominated in the past, like Jon Batiste.
ISTG IM GONNA BURRN EVERYTHING pic.twitter.com/kHrVFsS4j4
— 제이
Believe it or not, but this is not the only apparent double standard against BTS. Others noticed that while announcers were shown reading with the listing of the nominees on-screen, BTS were not.
TELL ME IF THIS ISNT UNFAIR!?!??? THIS IS SOO FREAKING ?!?!?
They were 1-time Grammy nominee and they weren't shown while announcing that 1 nomination!?? SCAMMYS U THINK WE CANT SEE WHAT U ARE DOING!??@RecordingAcad pic.twitter.com/LiLIYCLWd8
— ⟭⟬♡ (@BTSupdate_7) November 23, 2021
They also didn’t show their faces when they were announcing the nomination :/ pic.twitter.com/RolmkqeEjA
— ????
(@PeachyBooo) November 23, 2021
Instead, footage of BTS was shown right before the members read off the nominees. While the nominees were read, the nominees’ names, along with their albums, appeared on the screen. Afterward, BTS appeared again for their final message.
Your browser does not support video.| Recording Academy
Måneskin was also treated similarly. Like BTS, they’re an international group (they are from Italy). The only difference is that they’ve not been nominated for a GRAMMY previously, which BTS has. Regardless, it would have been nice for all artists to be respected equally.
They didn’t have a description for Maneskin either pic.twitter.com/Y8xBadtuMk
— Nancy (@scarlettarock) November 23, 2021
The live-streamed event began on a hopeful note as CEO Harvey Mason, Jr. preached a positive and inclusive message before announcing the changes the Recording Academy has made this year.
This is a new academy, one that is driven to action and that has doubled down on the commitment to meeting the needs of the music community… While change and progress are key drivers of our actions, one thing will always remain — the Grammy Award is the only peer-driven and peer-voted recognition in music. We are honored to work alongside the music community year-round to further refine and protect the integrity of the awards process.
— CEO Harvey Mason, Jr.
Nevertheless, even with two new categories, things remained the same in regards to diversity. New categories “Best Global Music Performance” (Global Music Field) and “Best Música Urbana Album” (Latin Music Field) contributed to the total of 88 categories. Still, popular international music like K-Pop continues to be unrecognized by the Recording Academy, and netizens are taking notice.
— call me whatever you want (@cynthiaKTH) November 23, 2021
imagine promoting inclusivity on nominations and not nominating THE music video that promoted inclusivity. you might need to rethink your brand, scammys
— ann ᶜᵒᵒᵏʸ ᵐᶦᶜ
| ebbg (@__gulliver) November 23, 2021
Considering all of BTS’s accomplishments this year, breaking multiple records, it seems unbelievable that the group is not nominated for more.
butter stayed on billboard as #1 for CONSECUTIVE WEEKS AND WASN’T NOMINATED FOR SONG OF THE YEAR???? ARE U KIDDING ME?
— anne (@flmvantes) November 23, 2021
DO THEY KNOW BTS BROKE THE MOST RECORDS ?! IN TERMS OF ALBUMS AND SONGS TOO , ARE U KIDDING ME ?
— Vid⁷ (@btseons) November 23, 2021
The 2022 GRAMMY Awards will be on Monday, January 31, on CBC Television Network and Paramount+.
You can watch the full 2022 GRAMMYs Awards Show Nominations Livestream Event below:
NOW LIVE
Harvey Mason Jr., #RecordingAcademy President/CEO, is announcing this year's #GRAMMYs nominees!
WATCH. https://t.co/WzKIndGKqJ
— Recording Academy / GRAMMYs (@RecordingAcad) November 23, 2021
관련자료
-
링크
