(G)I-DLE’s Soyeon, aespa’s Winter, And IVE’s Liz’s “Nobody” Collaboration Called Out For Poor Editing

While it’s common for K-Pop idols’ photos to be edited, some professionals go too far.

4th Gen leading ladies (G)I-DLE‘s Soyeon, aespa‘s Winter, and IVE‘s Liz teamed up for the collaboration song, “Nobody.”

While fans were excited about these three power vocalists on a track together, some were disappointed that it appeared the idols never actually worked together in person.

when three queens link up to make a bop winter, liz, and soyeon’s nobody is out now everywhere! pic.twitter.com/6oSaVyN2bt

— ‎‏ً (@wntrult) November 16, 2023

winter, soyeon, and liz did their big one with nobody this song is a bop pic.twitter.com/ObZBKYk3RJ

— ‎‏ً (@wntrult) November 16, 2023

Based on the music videos’ editing, they weren’t together. For instance, we see each woman on the same set but never together until the very last shot, which is non-moving.

why did they have to edit them together like you couldnt get all three of them in the same room for one second?? the mv is so awkward cus theyre all separate…. like the song is flames but you couldnt get liz winter and soyeon in the same room together for a minute….

— may Junie ︎ (@aespabur) November 16, 2023

I’m kinda mad Soyeon/Liz/Winter don’t have any scenes together like… I know it’s probably because of their mismatching schedules but what’s the point of collabing at this point

— camtheworld slowdamage (@riamurin) November 16, 2023

the winter liz soyeon song is great they all look gorgeous and everything but it irks me that they weren't able to film anything together like did they even know who else was gonna be on the song? can we bring back real fucking collabs cmon…let people have fun again…

— jem (@kyufront) November 16, 2023

This still from the MV is also being used as a promotional image. Yet, eagle-eyed netizens noticed poor editing of the shot, further proving the idols were never together.

They thought each idol’s face looked unusual, particularly Soyeon’s eyes. It also looked as if Liz and Soyeon were just automatically selected from their respective original photos and placed onto the image of Winter.

what they did: pic.twitter.com/lMKNkpiTnQ

— (@yuqiilyy) November 16, 2023

Is it a Photoshop fail…or PicsArt?